n a i j a t e c h t a l k

April 21, 2008

Nigerian banks and their Automatic Money Releasing Machines

Filed under: I.T Security, Nigerian Banks, e-Commerce, money matters — Admin @ 3:37 pm

Still on Nigerian banks and their ATMs, I think the best job one can do today is being a security guard at these banks.

Sometime ago, a friend(Bros.K) gisted me of his experience on a Sunday night as he wanted to go make a withdrawal at an ATM machine near his area. Sticking in his card, and requesting for NGN5,000.00(five-thousand Naira), he was surprised at what happened next. According to my guy’s story, the machine first released NGN10,000.00(ten thousand Naira), twice, making 20,000.00(twenty thousand Naira). It paused for like 2-minutes, then it released NGN20,000.00(twenty-thousand Naira), after which it(ATM machine) released his(Bros.K’s) requested NGN5,000.00(five-thousand Naira), making a total of NGN45,000.00(forty-five thousand Naira).

Bros.K, totally amused thought that perhaps the whole 45K was being deducted from his account balance. After his card was released, he stuck it in again, this time just to check his balance. He noted that it decreased only by NGN5,000.00(five-thousand Naira). Thinking about what to do next, he quickly noticed the security guard who by now had drawn close, and was standing behind him, and who was all smiles (he had watched the whole scene).

Turning around to face the guard, the guard goes: my broda, these thins sef, wey no dey work. Only God go help us for dis country o………………….bros mi, yo go see us small o, abi, make we take am buy pure water.

Bros.K tried to explain…… that perhaps the machine was releasing the money’s meant for people who attempted making withdrawals before he arrived, but to no avail, however, he(bros.K) said he was more surprised by the ‘lack-of-surprise’ of the security guards, who were all smiles. In fact, the second guard who later drew near confirmed that it was not the first time the machine would just start ‘releasing money by itself’.

With the guards expecting bros.K to share a little of the money with them, my guy made up his mind to return to the branch the next morning to return it over the counter. Not sure what the reaction of the guards will be, should he want to leave with the loot, he parted with NGN3,000.00(three-thousand Naira) with a promise that he will ’see’ them next time he comes around.

The next morning, bros.K showed up at the bank with his story of yester-night. The guards were happy to see him, but dumbfounded when he informed them that he came to return the money to the bank manager. Worse, even the counter ladies were not too surprised either. Wishing to make sure the event was noted and recorded, he asked to speak to the branch manager, a ’she’, to whom he turned over NGN40,000.00, left his name address and phone-number. According to bros.K, all the lady had to say was ‘thank you sir’.

Thank God for one-good Samaritan, but considering our make-money-by-all-means economic mind-set, I could just about estimate amounts that would have been debited into customers accounts, yet the cash fell into the wrong-customer’s hands.

Only God knows the amount/s of money that these Automatic Money Releasing Machines cough out by themselves in the middle of the night, at odd hours especially into the hands of such security guards - who have gotten the drift and secured their own ATM cards which they could use for ‘testing purposes’ in the middle of the night.

Very well, it doesn’t take Nigerians time to find out flaws in every hook and corner of technology.

Putting these security guards on the spot, I believe that in no time, these guys will become big boys, by the time the ATM machine in their banks/branches dispenses its contents into their hands freely during the night when no one is watching - every day of the week, and while customers continue to make all sorts of complaints in the morning.

No wonder, their Customer care phone lines are all dead.

 

Technorati Tags: ,,

the UBA and their card seizing ATMs

Filed under: Nigerian Banks, e-Commerce, financial independence, money matters — Admin @ 3:06 pm

Sometime ago, I blogged about the UBA and my ordeal with their ATM card. I just dropped by the bank a couple of minutes ago, to get some cash, lo and behold, after sticking in my card and keying in my PIN number, I was taken to the screen where I am to punch in the amount I would want to cash, only to be told that my PIN number was wrong.

After 3-tries, the machine seized my card, and issued me a piece of paper saying: the transaction was declined by your financial institution…..blah, blah, blah. It was then it occurred to me that ‘hey, I didn’t meet anyone withdrawing from the ATM upon my arrival‘….how come? on a Monday afternoon, and at a time when the branch is usually jam-packed? definitely, something was wrong.

My frowning face and I went inside the bank only to meet a lady in charge of the ATM who was not much surprised by my complaint: your ATM has seized my card.

UBA lady: sir, you didn’t key in the correct PIN number, thats why the machine  seized it your card.

Tux: Is it not a 4-digit number, excuse me madam, that thing is malfunctioning and you know it. All I expected you to say is ’sorry’. I use the same PIN for UBA and my other bank for which I also have an ATM, so there’s no way I could have forgotten/mistaken the PIN. Besides I still used that bank’s ATM this morning to confirm a payment into my account in their bank.

UBA lady: if the PIN is correct, it won’t have seized your card.

Tux: ehen, anyway I am not here to argue with you. You are a staff and I am a customer, and pls what I need is that the issue to be resolved, not an argument.

UBA lady: sir, pls come back tomorrow. We cannot retrieve the card today.

Tux: come back tomorrow? I need money today, and you are telling me come back tomorrow.

UBA lady: you can join the queue to withdraw with your withdrawal slip book.

Tux: Queue? what is the purpose of having an ATM if I always have to go around with my card and my withdrawal slip booklet? Your ATM isn’t working well, why allow it to be seizing cards.

UBA lady: sir, we can’t pay you without your booklet.

Tux: you will pay o. You will pay. Your machine is not working and you are telling me that you cannot pay me without my booklet, so I should go home and bring the booklet just because the machine isn’t working. If you cannot pay me without a slip, I need my card.

Aunty, see, if you cannot help me, let me know. I’m not here to waste my time. I’ll find someone else. Can I speak to the branch manager………..

thats when her ears straightened up……

p.s…as I was exchanging words with the UBA staff, there were 3-other customers with the same complaint.

……………..the long story short, I was given a withdrawal slip with which I made my intended withdrawal, only after raising-my-voice, and putting myself in mode ‘about to spark’.

 

Note: all these ATMs deployed by banks are not full fledged ATMs, for the fact that deposits are not accepted. They are just performing half(cash dispensing) of their expected function and yet they are not performing it well.

(Automatic Teller Machine machine) A banking terminal that accepts deposits and dispenses cash. ATMs are activated by inserting a cash or credit card that contains the user’s account number and PIN on a magnetic stripe. The ATM calls up the bank’s computers to verify the balance, dispenses the cash and then transmits a completed transaction notice. The word “machine” in the term “ATM machine” is certainly redundant, but widely used.

source: ATM Machine on pcmag.com

The bottleneck: why should a bank like the UBA deploy ATM machines whose functionality is on/off, on/off, on/off, blinking like NEPA light? and yet these banks claim to be providing Added Value to their customers.

 

 

Technorati Tags: ,
Older Posts »
  • Blog Stats

  • Blog at WordPress.com.